In the opening paragraphs, both characters are seen as dominant figures within their stories. Macbeth is look upon highly in opening of his story, he shows no flaws within his character and his Captain describes him as ‘brave’ and follows on saying his status and reputation is ‘well deserved’ as he was a fierce warrior on the battlefield and sought for nothing but victory. Macbeth prowess is shown within the Captain’s description of him where he says ‘Disdaining fortune, his brandishing steel’ what this suggests to us is that Macbeth is predominant difference and the backbone of his army, they had dependence on him to deliver and the win the war because of his ability to operate his weapon . ‘Disdaining fortune’ is an adjective that tells us Macbeth was amused of how simple the task was to defeat the enemy. The ease is emphasised where one strike of dagger ‘split him open’ regarding to how he dealt with the leader of the enemy MacDonwald. The use of adjectives portrays the ferociousness energy has to succeed. Shakespeare does this to give the audience that Macbeth is a positive character as he shows qualities of being a leader as he took the war on his shoulders to succeed. However, Macbeth gruesome and remorseless executions against his enemies hints that there is a possibility of him of changing as his capability of producing horror acts questions Macbeth’s true colour. These events foreshadows events we won’t expect from Macbeth in the early instance.
In comparison, Scrooge in the opening of his novella is pictured to be very flawed and is described to be selfish and cold hearted. We are shown Scrooge’s flaws through his responses he gives his nephew who visits him and wishes him ‘Merry Christmas’ Scrooge responds ‘Bah, humbug’ indicating to the reader that he’s not a believer of Christmas and sees it as waste of time. It proves his controversy as he’s not any good spirit within the festive period nor is he happy to see his nephew who is family. It shows to the reader that Scrooge is a lonely person and is detached from his loved ones as he is not spirited within a festive period where it’s full of positivity and love. Scrooge’s flaws are also seen in the retaliation he has when asked by visiting charity workers to help the poor. Scrooge replies with sheer arrogance, we are shown when he replies ‘I can’t afford to make idle people merry’ shows his reluctance to give away to the poor shows his stingy persona. The use of adjective ‘idle’ confirms that Scrooge is a very cold hearted person as he’s stating that the homeless have no value and he enforces his hatred for homeless people as he says they should rather die as it would ‘decrease the surplus population’ Scrooge is implying that he’d rather have worthless people who contribute nothing dead than aiming to help them to productive in society. Charles Dickens has chosen to given the first impressions of Scrooge as a money grabbing egocentric old man to relate to his hard past of when the spent time in the debtor’s prison as his father was financially irresponsible. Where the happiness was trapped outside.
As we get further to the stories both characters experience some sort of supernatural creatures brainwashing their minds. With Macbeth the witches predict the future outcomes of his life which leaves him in vulnerability and Scrooge receives a visit from his old friend’s ghost Marley who also warns him of how his life will unfold should he not change his character. These two events leave both of them in clear confusion of what to do next. But these visits is the start of contrasting journeys. Macbeth’s hard image starts to deteriorate as now Lady Macbeth starts to dictate manipulate him and Scrooge is now re-evaluating his life and how he treats people. We see these changes from Macbeth where he starts over thinking the deed of killing the king. ‘We’d jump the life to come. But in these cases We still have judgement’ What this suggests to us is that Macbeth is aware of how severe killing the king is and shows uncertainty on whether to proceed as he fears that his reputation and judgement would be affected should be caught by authorities. He also acknowledges that killing the king is a huge gamble as he would moving to a position in life that he is not necessarily prepared for. It demonstrates relapses of weakness as he is not able to make decisions himself and has let his partner control him and dictate him when he as the male figure should of been the more dominant and more in control of their greed to be at the top. The events of his brutality within the early stages of play foreshadowed him replicating something drastic as he shows the power to do so.This part of his story shows huge flaws in his character his as he had ambitions of being at the top and eliminating whoever is in his path, taking no regards of what was to come and how his actions would leave his legacy. The hunger of success got to him mentally. Shakespeare does this to add tension to he story as we witness a flip into the charcter of Macbeth. It fools the audience that Macbeth as the opening Macbeth seems to be an honest and loyal man but here his true colours are shown.
Similarly Scrooge’s hard image starts to dim as Marley’s ghost comes along and warns him about how his life would unfold should he continue living in negatively and cooperate. The flaws of Scrooge fall slightly as he is intimidated by the presence of the ghost who is confronting him, but he still shows his arrogance as he replies aggressively and makes sarcastic remarks but as the reader it is noticeable that Scrooge is frightened and in clear confusion as he is trying hard to not believe that the presence of the ghost is real. ”Scrooge fell upon his knees, and clasped his hands before his face. “ shows us the fear Scrooge had when Marley reveals his head to convince that he was really here. The fact that Scrooge ‘clapsed his hands before his face’ suggests to us that the ghost was a significant figure in Scrooge’s life as he is almost in disbelief of what he is witnessing. It shows us that Scrooge has a soft side to him and that his hard character was just really an act. The presence of the ghost proves that Scrooge holds strong emotions and that he is just like any other person, the visit of the ghost bring Scrooge back to reality. Similarly, Charles Dickens does this to add tension to the story as we start to notice the behaviour and character of Scrooge is starting to crack and his true nature is starting to come out as he shows sensitivity which he didn’t show in the opening of the play.
Further along the stories, we endure the climaxes of both ends as Macbeth completes the dreadful act in killing the king which leaves him shell-shocked although he has fulfilled his ambition of being at the top. Scrooge is expecting 3 spirits which traumatizes him as the reveals to him what he should expect should he continue to be cold-hearted to others. Scrooge seems to come to realisation that the path is taking is leading him to no where but his death bed. Macbeth finds himself in no man land as he has

Recent Comments